Jack Flaherty’s 2025 campaign with the Detroit Tigers has been anything but smooth, and frustration is mounting among fans and analysts alike. Sporting a 5-9 record and a 4.84 ERA, Flaherty has faced sharp criticism — including pointed comments from broadcaster Mark Champion, who recently called the pitcher “a little sketchy these days” on social media.
Flaherty’s most recent start against the Washington Nationals highlighted his ongoing issues: he allowed three runs over five innings but struck out nine, showing glimpses of his past dominance even as early runs raised concerns. Once a rising star who finished fourth in NL Cy Young voting back in 2019, Flaherty’s current struggles stand in stark contrast to his earlier success.
His recent stretch has been especially rocky, posting a 9.45 ERA and 1.88 WHIP over his last three starts. Despite flashes of potential — like his solid 109 strikeouts over 89.1 innings this year — his inconsistency has left many doubting whether he can recapture his former brilliance.
With the Tigers fighting to stay ahead of the Cleveland Guardians in the playoff race, Flaherty’s performance could prove pivotal. Tigers fans are hoping he can find his rhythm down the stretch and provide the stability the rotation desperately needs.
Jack Flaherty Under Fire as Tigers Pitcher Struggles Through Rough Season
