Should the Lions Re-Sign Al-Quadin Muhammad? Here’s the Case for (and Against) Bringing Him Back in 2025
The Detroit Lions took a midseason gamble on Al-Quadin Muhammad in 2024, signing him to the practice squad after injuries devastated their defensive line. That move paid off, as the veteran edge rusher became a valuable rotational piece down the stretch. Now, with Muhammad set to hit free agency, the Lions have to decide whether to bring him back or move on.
Why the Lions Should Re-Sign Muhammad
Muhammad proved he could be an effective pass rusher in limited snaps, finishing with 26 QB pressures, three sacks, and seven tackles in just 10 games (two starts). His ability to set the edge and bring high energy to the pass rush was exactly what the Lions needed after injuries took a toll. Dan Campbell even praised his improvement, saying Muhammad got “better and better” as the season went on.
The biggest argument for re-signing Muhammad is familiarity and cost. At 30 years old, he’s unlikely to demand much more than a veteran minimum contract (his 2024 base salary was just $1.125 million). Bringing him back on a one-year deal would give the Lions a reliable depth piece without overcommitting resources.
Why the Lions Should Let Muhammad Walk
While Muhammad was serviceable, he wasn’t a game-changer. His Pro Football Focus (PFF) grades were below average across the board:
Overall defense: 60.7
Run defense: 54.7
Tackling: 55.3
Pass rush: 59.8
With the Lions looking to build a Super Bowl-caliber defense, they may prefer to invest in younger talent with more upside. Detroit’s front office, led by Brad Holmes, has shown a commitment to finding and developing high-ceiling players, and that roster spot could go to a draft pick or a younger free agent who brings more long-term potential.
Final Verdict: Will Muhammad Be Back?
There’s a strong chance the Lions bring Muhammad back—at least for training camp. He fits the culture, knows the system, and provides cheap depth at a key position. But if Detroit finds a more dynamic edge rusher in free agency or the draft, Muhammad could be on the outside looking in.
Would you bring him back for another season?
Detroit Lions 2025 Free Agency: Why Al-Quadin Muhammad Should Stick Around
