By Josh 
The Pittsburgh Steelers are heading into the 2025 offseason with plenty of uncertainty at the quarterback position. While names like Aaron Rodgers and Trevor Lawrence have surfaced in rumors, the most realistic option appears to be Justin Fields—under one condition.
According to ESPN’s Jeremy Fowler, Fields is open to a return to Pittsburgh, but he wants a guaranteed starting role.
“Fields wants a realistic shot to start. He wants a clear path to be the guy for a full season, which he was not last year.”
— Jeremy Fowler, ESPN
Fields’ 2024 Season & the Steelers’ Dilemma
The Steelers acquired Fields after his rocky tenure with the Chicago Bears, and he initially led the team to a 4-2 record before Russell Wilson took over as the starter.
- Fields’ 2024 performance (before benching):
- Showed flashes of his athleticism and playmaking ability
- Helped the Steelers get off to a strong start
- Benched in favor of Russell Wilson, despite controversy
Wilson had some success, finishing 6-5 as a starter, but the team ultimately struggled down the stretch. Now, both quarterbacks are in limbo as Pittsburgh evaluates its options.
Should Fields Get the Job?
Fields’ demand raises a crucial question:
- Do the Steelers believe in Fields enough to commit to him long-term?
- Or should the team explore other options before making a decision?
Fields still possesses first-round pedigree, is only 25 years old, and offers a unique skill set. But handing him the job outright—rather than having him earn it—might not be the best approach.
The Steelers’ Quarterback Outlook
With Wilson also expressing interest in staying, Pittsburgh has multiple paths forward:
- Re-sign Fields and make him the starter
- Stick with Wilson and look for additional competition
- Pursue a high-profile veteran or draft a new QB
Ultimately, the Steelers’ ideal QB for 2025 should win the job based on performance—not a promise.