
As Alabama ushers in a new chapter at quarterback, one of the Crimson Tide’s most decorated signal-callers, AJ McCarron, isn’t holding back his thoughts. The former national champion offered a blunt and honest message to fans as Ty Simpson officially steps into the starting role in Tuscaloosa.
Speaking on a recent podcast appearance, McCarron addressed the high expectations and pressure that inevitably come with being Alabama’s quarterback, especially in the wake of legends like Bryce Young, Tua Tagovailoa, and himself.
“You’ve got to give the kid a chance,” McCarron said. “Everyone wants perfection from Day One, but that’s not how it works. Ty’s got the tools. What he needs now is patience and support—not people tearing him down after one mistake.”
McCarron, who led Alabama to back-to-back national championships in 2011 and 2012, knows the spotlight in Tuscaloosa can be unforgiving. He warned that unrealistic expectations can damage a young quarterback’s confidence and derail development.
“When I took over, there were growing pains too,” he added. “We didn’t win every game by 40. Fans have to remember: it’s a process.”
Ty Simpson, a former five-star recruit, has waited for his opportunity behind Jalen Milroe and others. Now that his moment has arrived, the pressure is mounting for him to deliver right away. But according to McCarron, greatness takes time to build—and Simpson deserves the breathing room to grow into the role.
“This isn’t PlayStation. He’s not going to throw five touchdowns every game,” McCarron quipped. “Let him make mistakes. Let him learn. That’s what real fans do—support through the ups and the downs.”
McCarron also praised Simpson’s work ethic and poise in spring practices, saying the young quarterback reminds him of some of Alabama’s greats with his calm demeanor and strong football IQ.
As Alabama gears up for the 2025 season, the message from one Tide legend to the fan base is clear: trust the process, and give Ty Simpson the time and space he needs to lead.
“He’s not trying to be the next Bryce or Tua,” McCarron concluded. “He’s trying to be the first Ty Simpson—and that’s more than enough.”