After Saturday’s discussion, I thought I had Sunday’s Question of the Day all figured out. But the Detroit Lions threw a wrench in my plans by promoting linebackers coach Kelvin Sheppard to fill the defensive coordinator role vacated by Aaron Glenn, who’s now headed to the New York Jets.

This move wasn’t entirely unexpected. Sheppard has been a standout coach for Detroit over the past few seasons. His leadership ability is undeniable, and his work with the team’s linebackers has led to the best performances we’ve seen from that group in years. However, judging by fan reactions across social media on Saturday, the decision has been met with mixed feelings. So here’s today’s question:

Do you approve of Kelvin Sheppard being named the Lions’ defensive coordinator?

My answer: Yes, but…

I’m thrilled for Sheppard. He’s earned this opportunity through hard work and results. His development of players like Alex Anzalone, Jack Campbell, Malcolm Rodriguez, and others speaks for itself. From the first time Sheppard addressed the media, it was clear he has the qualities of a future head coach. He has that special “it” factor that can’t be taught.

One of the biggest endorsements for Sheppard came last month from Aaron Glenn himself, who said:

“Having Shep there with me, he’s been there from the beginning, and he knows exactly how I think—exactly. And that’s a guy that I’ve been actually mentoring to be in the DC role at some point. I think he’s damn near close, if not there, to be ready to do that. He’s a damn good coach.”

Dan Campbell, too, highlighted Sheppard’s understanding of the Lions’ defensive philosophy, saying they didn’t want to stray from their system or terminology. In that sense, Sheppard feels like the perfect fit.

That said, I can’t help but feel a bit disappointed that the Lions didn’t explore external candidates. While it’s true the team’s defensive struggles over the past four seasons are largely due to talent issues—too young in the first three years and riddled with injuries this past season—a fresh perspective could have been valuable. For example, I was intrigued by the idea of someone like Dennis Allen, the former Saints defensive coordinator, stepping into the role. He likely would have kept a similar defensive scheme while adding his own insights and experience.

Under Campbell, the Lions have been successful at attracting high-quality coaching talent. Look no further than the hiring of defensive line coach Kacy Rodgers, who had interest from both the Packers and Buccaneers. With that in mind, I was hopeful Detroit would pursue an experienced, outside candidate for this critical role.

Instead, they stayed in-house with Sheppard. While I fully believe in his potential, this will be his first time calling plays, and he’s taking on the responsibility in what will undoubtedly be a high-pressure 2025 season.

Still, I’m ultimately supportive of this decision because this is how strong organizations operate. When coordinators leave, teams should already have succession plans in place, and it’s smart to reward and promote from within when it makes sense. The Lions have clearly been grooming Sheppard for this moment, and I believe he’s ready for the challenge.

For now, I give the Lions a B+ grade for this hire. What about you?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *