By Josh 
George Pickens’ tumultuous 2024 season with the Pittsburgh Steelers has raised significant questions about his future with the team. Between on-field penalties, off-field issues, and his inability to address controversies directly, Pickens has drawn criticism from fans and former players alike. His undeniable talent as a receiver is overshadowed by concerns about his maturity and discipline, casting doubt on whether he aligns with the Steelers’ storied culture of professionalism.
Former Steelers lineman Kendall Simmons didn’t hold back during an appearance on the Joba and the Mouth Show, stating, “If you gonna be a cancer, you gotta go.” Simmons acknowledged Pickens’ superstar potential but warned that his off-field behavior could limit his success and potentially hasten his exit from Pittsburgh.
Head coach Mike Tomlin has largely shielded Pickens publicly, but it’s unclear whether internal efforts to help the receiver mature have had any meaningful impact. Pickens’ penchant for drawing attention for the wrong reasons—like late-game penalties or accusations of being a lazy route runner—has only fueled trade speculation, especially with a contract extension on the horizon.
The Steelers, known for letting talented players go when necessary, may consider moving on from Pickens if they can strengthen their receiving corps in the offseason. While his raw talent makes him a dangerous playmaker, his behavior has prompted some to question whether his presence aligns with the team’s long-term goals. As Pittsburgh evaluates its options, the coming months could determine whether Pickens has a future with the franchise—or if Simmons’ prediction of his departure becomes reality.