By Blessing 
The Dallas Cowboys exceeded expectations in 2024, finishing with a 7-9 record under Cooper Rush. While some feared the team would collapse, their performance still may not be enough to secure Mike McCarthy’s job as head coach. His future remains uncertain heading into a crucial offseason.
The NFC East is now one of the NFL’s toughest divisions. The Eagles seem set to dominate for years, while the Commanders, with rookie quarterback Jayden Daniels, have transformed into a competitive force. The Cowboys risk being overshadowed by these rivals unless significant changes are made.
McCarthy’s fate is less clear than it once seemed, especially after the team’s late-season wins. However, moving on from him might not be as disruptive as some might think. According to Albert Breer of *Sports Illustrated*, many of McCarthy’s assistant coaches are on expiring contracts. This provides the Cowboys’ front office with an opportunity to make sweeping changes without committing to short-term deals for the current staff.
One of the key assistants is offensive coordinator Brian Schottenheimer. Despite holding the title, Schottenheimer does not call plays and hasn’t done much to elevate his profile during his time in Dallas. It’s unlikely he will attract significant interest from other teams this offseason.
Defensive coordinator Mike Zimmer, meanwhile, has had an inconsistent year. Injuries and other challenges have made it difficult for him to implement his defensive strategies fully. While Zimmer has had some strong performances, his struggles make it clear that the Cowboys could benefit from a fresh approach.
Change in the front office isn’t an option, as owner Jerry Jones remains firmly in control of all major decisions. Similarly, the team isn’t likely to move on from quarterback Dak Prescott due to his substantial contract. The coaching staff, then, becomes the most logical area for a major overhaul.
McCarthy hasn’t been a complete failure as a head coach, especially considering the injuries and challenges the team has faced under his leadership. However, his tenure has been marked by disappointment, and it’s clear that the Cowboys need a new direction. By parting ways with McCarthy, Dallas could take the first step toward reshaping its future and building a team capable of competing with the division’s rising powerhouses.