By Sunday 
Toronto Weighs Its Options as Alonso’s Market Takes a Shift
Pete Alonso remains one of the most sought-after sluggers in free agency, but his market has been complicated by recent developments surrounding the New York Mets. With the team’s negotiations taking shape, the Toronto Blue Jays find themselves at a crossroads regarding their pursuit of the four-time National League All-Star.
Alonso’s Free Agency Stalls as Options Dwindle
Despite his impressive track record, Alonso has yet to find a long-term deal that meets his expectations. The 30-year-old first baseman has been a consistent power threat, racking up 34 home runs and 88 RBIs last season. His career .854 OPS and durability make him an attractive option for any team looking to add offensive firepower.
However, Alonso’s market has been surprisingly quiet. While several teams initially expressed interest, reports now indicate that the race for his signature has narrowed to just two contenders—the Mets and the Blue Jays.
Toronto’s Offer and Alonso’s Response
According to MLB insider Hector Gomez, Toronto has extended a three-year offer to Alonso, signaling their willingness to bring his bat north of the border.
“SOURCE: The #BlueJays have offers out to both Pete Alonso (3 years) and Alex Bregman (6 years). The Jays are in play to land either of them,” Gomez reported.
This move comes after Alonso reportedly turned down a three-year, $70 million offer from the Mets (via SNY’s Andy Martino). If Toronto’s proposal is in the same ballpark, it raises questions about whether Alonso sees the Blue Jays as a preferable landing spot.
Mets News Puts Pressure on Toronto
The Mets have remained firm in their negotiations with Alonso, unwilling to budge beyond their initial offer. However, recent reports suggest that Alonso is now more likely to return to New York.
This shift forces the Blue Jays into a tough decision—should they increase their offer to outbid the Mets, or pivot to alternative options? Toronto has already been active this offseason, securing three-time Cy Young winner Max Scherzer, but adding a power-hitting first baseman remains a priority.
What’s Next for the Blue Jays?
If Alonso is indeed leaning toward staying in Queens, the Blue Jays may need to act fast. They could consider sweetening their deal or turning their attention to other available bats. With Spring Training approaching, Toronto’s front office must decide whether Alonso is worth the extra investment or if their resources are better spent elsewhere.
For now, the ball is in Alonso’s court, and the Blue Jays can only wait to see if their offer is enough to lure him away from New York.