Flexible Contract Could Keep Star Slugger in New York While Offering Future Freedom
Pete Alonso is making moves to stay in Queens—on his terms. According to reports from Jim Duquette citing “league sources,” Alonso and his high-profile agent, Scott Boras, have proposed a three-year contract to the New York Mets. The unique offer includes opt-outs after each season, granting Alonso flexibility to revisit free agency if the timing feels right. Interestingly, the Mets are reportedly the only team to receive this proposal, signaling Alonso’s desire to remain in New York while keeping his long-term options open.
A Surprising Shift from Long-Term to Short-Term Security
This proposed deal is a notable shift from recent reports suggesting Alonso was pursuing a six-year contract. Just a day before Duquette’s report, Jon Heyman revealed Alonso was seeking “at least” a six-year commitment. Now, this shorter, opt-out-friendly deal suggests a strategic pivot.
The structure of the contract offers Alonso a safety net while allowing him to bet on himself. If he rebounds with a standout 2025 season, he can explore more lucrative opportunities. If not, he still has the security of a multi-year deal with the Mets.
Alonso’s 2024 Performance Raises Questions
Alonso’s performance in 2024 was solid but not up to his usual standards. He finished the season with a .240 batting average, a .329 on-base percentage, and a .459 slugging percentage, paired with 34 home runs. His OPS+ of 123 was respectable, but the year marked his lowest slugging percentage, fewest home runs, and highest strikeout rate in a full season.
These numbers might have influenced Alonso’s shift toward a shorter contract with opt-outs. It’s a calculated move that allows him to rebuild value while still securing immediate financial security.
Mets Still the Best Fit
Despite ongoing speculation about other suitors, notably the San Francisco Giants, a Mets reunion remains the most logical fit. Alonso has been a cornerstone of the Mets’ lineup since his electrifying rookie season. His leadership and fan appeal make him difficult to replace.
The proposed deal could serve as a middle ground: it rewards Alonso with security while giving the Mets continuity without a long-term burden. For Alonso, it’s a chance to stay in a familiar environment as he works to regain peak form.
Revisiting Past Contract Talks
Alonso’s free agency journey began long before this offseason. In the summer of 2023, he reportedly turned down a seven-year, $158 million extension from the Mets. His decision to reject that offer hints at his desire for either a bigger payday or more control over his future. This latest proposal reflects that same mindset—prioritizing flexibility over a long-term lock-in.
What’s Next for Alonso and the Mets?
The Mets now face a critical decision. Do they accept Alonso’s proposal and keep their star slugger in the lineup with built-in flexibility? Or do they pursue a different structure or even consider moving on?
For Alonso, this deal represents a smart balance of stability and freedom. For the Mets, it’s a chance to maintain a franchise cornerstone without committing to an extended deal.
The ball is in the Mets’ court.