The Dallas Cowboys gave their fans plenty of reason to cheer in their win over the New York Giants, pulling off clutch plays and late-game heroics that reminded everyone of their star power. Dak Prescott stood tall, the defense forced turnovers, and big moments came from players all over the roster. In the moment, it felt like the Cowboys were proving they could be the contender they’ve long promised to be.
But outside of Dallas? The NFL world isn’t convinced.
In the latest NFL power rankings, the Cowboys still find themselves hovering outside the circle of true playoff contenders. Analysts point to the same concerns that have haunted Dallas in recent years — inconsistency on offense, shaky execution against elite teams, and questions about whether Mike McCarthy’s squad can put it all together when it matters most in January.
The frustrating part for fans is that Dallas has all the pieces. Micah Parsons continues to wreak havoc on defenses, CeeDee Lamb is emerging as one of the league’s most dynamic receivers, and Prescott has shown flashes of brilliance. Yet the national narrative continues to put the Cowboys a step below heavyweights like the 49ers, Lions, and Eagles.
The win over the Giants was a reminder that Dallas can rise to the moment. But until they string together performances like that against top-tier opponents, the Cowboys will still be fighting not just for victories — but for respect in the playoff conversation.
Dallas Outsmarts Giants, But NFL Rankings Keep Them in Check
